header image
HOME arrow COMMENTARIES arrow Middle East Conflict arrow Middle East Conflict arrow Israel's Subjugation of the Palestinians Must End Now
Israel's Subjugation of the Palestinians Must End Now PDF Print E-mail
User Rating: / 22
Written by Louay Safi   
Dec 28, 2008 at 06:52 PM

Israel pounded Gaza Strip in retaliation for rockets fired at its Southern borders, killing over 280 Palestinians and wounding hundreds more, over half of whom were civilians, and bringing destruction to the already deteriorating Palestinian infrastructure. Israel used F16 bombers against an essentially defenseless population. The greatest weapon in the Palestinian arsenal is inaccurate makeshift rockets with extremely short range that often miss their targets.  

In responding to questions by CBS’s Face-the-Nation this Sunday, Tzipi Levni, Israel’s foreign minister, justified the Israeli attacks by citing its rights to defend its citizens against attacks by Hamas. When asked whether Israel wants to reoccupy Gaza and overthrow Haman, she insisted that Israel does not wants to return to Gaza and that its military operations are limited to bring quiet to its southern borders.

The above narrative, intended to bring sympathy to Israel’s aggressive actions by depicting the Palestinians as the aggressors and Israel as the victim of aggression has little resemblance with the reality on the ground. The truth is that Israel has never freed Gaza from its heavy handed occupation, but only evacuated Jewish settlers when it became apparent that it could not guarantee their safety. In its retaliation against the Palestinians, Israel reduced Gaza into the largest concentration camp in world history. Placing people under siege is an act of war and aggression.

Sealed off completely from the outside world, Gazans are prisoners in their own land. Gaza which occupies a little less than 140 square miles (3 to 7 miles in width and 25 miles in length) is the home of over 1.4 million Palestinians. Suffocated in their tiny strip of land, Gazans are not allowed to travel, trade with the outside world, or even complain about the inhumane conditions imposed on them by Israel. Their painful narrative has never found its way to Western media, which has managed, to the determent of Western long term interests, to conceal the Palestinian narrative while amplifying the Israeli’s. With the exception of few astute observers, everyone who watches Western media knows that it is the Palestinians that must be blamed for their own suffering.

Israel’s efforts to beat its Palestinian subjects into submission flies in the face of every principle of political equity and social justice we cherish today, and our silence in the faith of the Israeli violation of the principles of freedom, equal dignity, and justice makes mockery of our cherished values, and is bound to undermine political freedom and reverse the progress modern society made in the last two centuries.

Apparently, Israel’s goal is to soften the Palestinians and bring them down on their knees. In reality, though, Israel is likely to widen and deepen the level of animosity towards it in the Palestinian territories and beyond. The history of the last sixty years shows that Israel’s reliance on force has widened and broadened the negative feelings towards it throughout the world, and has intensified the level of resistance against it in the Middle East.

Hamas can be faulted for targeting civilians, for being impatient with its Palestinian rivals, or even for adopting the wrong liberation strategy. But that does not by any means justify the collective punishment imposed on all Palestinians. Israel must take major responsibility for forcing the Palestinian people to overwhelmingly choose Hamas leadership when it chose to support settlement expansion while it was engaged in Peace negotiations. The Israeli expansion into the West Bank and Gaza squeezed the Palestinians into small cantons and into the orbit of Hamas as Mahmoud Abbas and his party appeared increasingly helpless and confused.

Changing the current dynamics requires less reliance on force and more reliance on good will and humane treatment of the Palestinians. Unfortunately, the Israeli leadership is trapped in a siege mentality that prevents it to see that it is turning the Palestinians and the rest of the Muslim world into a fierce enemy. Rather than ensuring peace for the Jewish people, it is building a record of aggression and injustice that future generations will find appalling, and that future Jews will find overwhelming and burdensome. Israel can create propaganda to cover its current aggression, but will never be able to erase the records of its aggression against defenseless people in the age of information explosion.

It is about time that all people of decency and foresight in Western society in general, and Western Jewry in particular, to pressure Israel to free the Palestinians of the harsh conditions of occupation, and to embark on a process of genuine peace with its neighbors.

This article appeared in the following publications:

. Online Journal
. Media Monitors Network
. iViews
. The American Muslim
. Middle East Online
. Official Wire
. Alarab Online

User Comments

Comment by Romesh Chander on 2008-12-30 16:16:13
There is one and only one solution to Israeli/Arab problem -- let them slug it out, and the winner takes all. If Jews lose, they get annihilated. If the Arabs lose, they get out of Israel/Palestine/Gaza area and move permanently to other Arab lands. There is no half-way solution. It is all or nothing. 

Comment by Nizam on 2009-01-01 06:57:31
I wonder, what path is left to the oppressed other than fighting back with whatever means they have?...

Comment by Tamim I on 2009-01-01 06:53:11
I put the blame on the Palestinian leaders and the dis-unity among them. The division amongst the leaders hurting the Cause and costing innocent paletinians lives. The same has been happening in Afghanistan.  

Comment by Kam on 2008-12-30 20:18:25
Arab-Israeli-Palestine problem has been simmering for such along time and I believe it should be brought to a meaningful closure. I see nothing wrong in trying novel solutions. As Romesh Chander suggests let Israelis and Palestinians slug it out. Winner takes all. Sooner the better. The world is tired of this pestering problem.

Comment by NN on 2010-04-14 14:57:15
MashAllah Dr. Louay Safi for writing this article! 
To other Muslim brother and sisters: 
Assalamu alaykum dears,  
1. Boycotting products that support this oppression. This includes Israeli, US made products. Please follow the link below to find brands to BOYCOTT.  
2. Distribute this info via copying, printing and telling friends and relatives.  
3. Print and have it on hand when going shopping.  
Let's take a STAND and DO what we can to help oppressed in Palestine from our own homes wherever we are. 
URL: http://www.inminds.com/boycott-brands.html 

Comment by Jamila Ibrahim on 2008-12-30 20:24:26
The article was great & I thank you for that. 
I coudn't sleep last night I was watching the videos about Gaza over & over & my hear was torn out over & over 
& I called my sister to ask about my Cousin who lives in Gaza then my sister said please phone her to make her 
happy, she was crying & I heard some explosion & asked her about it so she said yes that was some bombing I said hide under the ground she said we can't go anywhere& we have no food no gas for heat, we are freezing cold. 
How can the rest of the world see this & not to do anythig. 

Please login or register to add comments


The Qur'anic Narrative
The Qur'anic Narrative

Leading with Compassion
Leading with Compassion


Tensions and Transitions
in the Muslim World

Peace and the Limits of War

The Challenge of Modernity 


Blaming Islam

Foundation of Knowledge

Creative Commons License