header image
HOME arrow COMMENTARIES arrow Islam and Society arrow Islam and Society arrow Woman and the Masjid between Two Extremes
Woman and the Masjid between Two Extremes PDF Print E-mail
User Rating: / 2
PoorBest 
Written by Louay Safi   
Mar 08, 2005 at 07:00 PM

The masjid, better known in North America as the Islamic center, is the center of spiritual, social, educational, and, most recently, political activities of the American Muslim community. The masjid is also the place where Muslims of diverse cultural and ideological backgrounds meet and interact. The diversity of interpretations of Islamic sources and practices has created tensions, particularly in Islamic centers where the tendency is to impose strict interpretations about the appropriate place and role of Muslim women in the masjid and the community.

An increasing number of young Muslim women complain of restrictive arrangements and practices, impeding their ability to fully participate in educational and social programs. Many masjids today restrict the main prayer hall to men, and assign women to secluded quarters. Women are asking out laud: is this the place Islam assigns for us, or is it the imposition of cultural traditions? Some have even gone to the other extreme of rejecting all traditions and discarding all limits.

For Believing Men and Women

The masjid is a place for spiritual growth and development for all Muslims, and should be equally accessible for both genders. The Qur'an has set the spiritual and moral equality of men and women in explicit and unequivocal terms:


Allah has prepared forgiveness and great rewards for the Muslim men and women; for the believing men and women; for the devout men and women; for the truthful men and women; for the men and women who are patient and constant; the men and women who humble themselves; for the men and women who give charity; for the men and women who fast, for the men and women who guard their chastity; and the men and women who are exceedingly mindful of Allah. (Al-Ahzab 33:35)

Both men and women, the Qur'an stresses, have a moral obligation to develop themselves spiritually and morally, and to fulfill their social responsibilities. The masjid is, and has always been, the center of moral and spiritual learning and growth.

Likewise, the masjid is a public place for discussing issues of public concern and to respond to challenges facing the community. The Qur'an is also clear on the equal responsibility of both men and women for developing the public good:

The believing men and women are protectors and helpers of each other. They (collaborate) to promote all that is good and oppose all that is evil; establish prayers and give charity, and obey Allah and his Messenger. Those are the people whom Allah would grant mercy. Indeed Allah is Exalted and Wise. (Al-Tawbah 9:71)

Promoting public good and opposing evil are public duties equally required from men and women, and the masjid is the place where Muslim men and women can meet to plan community development and devise strategies for promoting public good.

The Prophet Affirms Equal Access

During the formative years of Islam women participated in public services, and shared the Masjid of the Prophet's main hall. Sharing the main prayer hall allowed women to fully engage in public debate and influence decisions affecting their lives and the life of the community. When the second Caliph Umar bin al-Khatab wanted to put a cap on dowry, he was challenged by a woman, who stood up in the middle of the masjid and pointed out that his proposed policy violated Islamic law. He conceded and the proposed policy was never carried out.

Although the Qur'an is clear on the spiritual and moral equality of men and women, the Prophet, recognizing the tendency of some men to be overprotective of their female relatives, cautioned the Muslim community against preventing women from frequenting the masjid:

Ibn Umar narrated: The Messenger of Allah, peace be with him, said: Do not deprive women of their share of the masjids, when they seek permission from you. Bilal said: By Allah, we would certainly prevent them. 'Abdullah said: I say that the Messenger of Allah, peace be with him, said it and you say: We would certainly prevent them! (Sahih Muslim Book 4, Number 891)

Ibn Umar also narrated: The Prophet, peace be with him, said, "Allow women to go to the Mosques at night." (Bukhari Volume 2, Book 13, Number 22)

Sidestepping Established Principles

The argument against women sharing the main prayer hall is based on the principle of “corruption prevention” (dar' al-mafasid). The principle states that "whatever leads to unlawful practices (haram) is in itself unlawful." The principle, though not widely accepted by Muslim jurists, has been extensively used to limit actions that are otherwise lawful under Shari'ah. It was invoked by some jurists to reject the use of radio, TV, press, and other inventions because these were used to promote corrupt practices. Indeed, by invoking the principle of "corruption prevention" many good practices and devices could be declared unlawful, including the use of the internet and popular governance, as both are open to abuse.

Employing the "corruption prevention" argument, a number of masjids have decided to assign secluded quarters for women, and have placed many restrictions on women’s use of the masjid's facilities. In recent visits to three Islamic centers, several Muslim women complained bitterly to me about their experiences with community leaders. They complained of their inability to participate in general lectures and discussions, of the quality of the quarters assigned to them, and of their reliance on audio and video systems that frequently cut them off from the ongoing lectures or discussions.

Assigning women to separate quarters during lectures and discussions does not “prevent corruption” but rather "prevent education and spiritual growth." I have heard many accounts of women completely immersed in conversations about shopping and cooking recipes during public lectures. The seclusion gives some women the feeling of distance and separation, and some women conclude that the events that take place in the main hall do not concern them. In such instances, the women’s quarters become less friendly to women who want to concentrate on learning and community issues.

Not all masjids embrace a mandatory seclusion policy. Many leading masjids, such as
Dulles Area Musim Society (ADAMS), ensure that women share the main hall, participate fully in learning and consultation, and take active role in running the masjid. Women serve on the executive board of ADAMS and on its board of trustees. 5 of the 13 Board of Trustees members are women, and ADAMS vice president is a women. While ADAMS gives full access to women to use its main prayer hall, it still permits women who want privacy to stay in a separate quarter, thereby ensuring the Muslim women with different needs and convictions have place in the masjid.

Preventing women from exercising established rights or undertake duties cannot be justified under argument of “corruption prevention.” This argument was used at the formative stage of Islamic society, but was rejected by early Muslims. Abdullah bin Umar rejected this same argument of prevention:

Ibn 'Umar reported: Grant permission to women for going to the mosque in the night. His son who was called Waqid said: Then they would make mischief. He (the narrator) said: He thumped his (son's) chest and said: I am narrating to you the hadith of the Messenger of Allah (may peace be upon him), and you say: No! (Sahih Muslim Book 4, Number 890)

Problems with Women's Seclusion

Assigning women a separate and secluded space does not only go against Qur'anic injunctions and the practices and directives of the Prophet, peace be with him, but is detrimental to the spiritual and moral growth of women and the development of the community.

Preventing women from gaining direct access to the main hall of the masjid, where lectures and study circles take place, deprives them from taking active role in learning. In addition to the psychological and emotional feeling of not taking active part in the meetings, the ability to interact with the speakers, to ask questions and offer comments, is impeded.

Secluding women deprive the emerging Muslim community from a growing number of young Muslim women who do expect, and rightly so, that the masjid does not take away their right to take active part in serving the community. When legitimate expectations are not met, and when the customs and cultural traditions are given priority, they often force women to stay away from the masjid, and hence from Islamic learning and activities.

Elevating the cultural traditions and customs of immigrants works against the very mission of the masjid, as it becomes an impediment for educating people of other faiths about Islam. Historically, Islam found home in different communities throughout the world because of its ability to accommodate local customs and cultures, as long as they are not in conflict with Islamic teachings. Immigrant communities would be betraying their mission and trust if they insist on imposing their customs and cultural traditions.

Women and Masjid's Governance

Women's leadership in the community is another contentious issue. Women have assumed, in some Islamic centers, key leadership positions, by serving on the executive boards, and leading key committees, while they are kept at arm's bay in others. Although Islam recognized the capacity of women to enjoy equal moral responsibility, as we saw earlier, many Muslim community managed, nonetheless, to curtail women's participation in public duties on social and rational grounds. The degree of limitations placed on women's ability to serve in public capacity varies across historical periods and fiqh schools.

Early jurists disagreed as to whether women can assume public office; while Ibn Jarir al-Tabari placed no limitations on women's right to assume the post of judge in all legal matters, al-Mawardi contended that women cannot be allowed to serve as judges under any circumstances. In between stands Abu Hanifa who allowed women to serve as judges except in cases involving commercial deals.

To their credit, early Muslim jurists recognized women's rights to serve in public capacity at times when many women have limited involvement in public life, and limited exposure to public service. Contemporary Muslim jurists should ensure that the original Qur'anic position of equal spiritual and moral rights and obligations is respected and advanced in today's society. This is more pressing today as the question of women capacity to exercise leadership and serve the community is put to rest through impressive track record of Muslim women achieving in the academia, professional work, and community service.

Our masjids must reflect the leading role played by American Muslim women by ensuring that they are represented on the masjid board and join the rank of leadership. The importance of women taking active part on the executive board and in executive committees is further underscored by the need to represent concerns that can not be expressed except by women, who feel the impact of decisions made by the masjid on the quality of life and participation of other women.

Swinging to the Other Extreme

Several feminist Muslims, supported by a network of progressive activists, have been pushing the pendulum to the other extreme. Their solution for limiting women to secluded quarters, and their marginalization in ultra conservative masjids, is to open the masjid to a mixed congregation led by women. The Progressive Muslim Union has already announced a mixed congregation to be led by Amina Wadud this month in New York. It is unfortunate that Muslim feminists are following in the footsteps of their secularist precursors, breaking all traditions, and engaging in experimentations that break out with formative principles and values. For individuals and movements interested in reforming attitudes and practices to take the opposite extreme can only hurt the reform agenda already underway throughout North America.

The recent push to break out with community and tradition goes far beyond any reform agenda. Reform requires that one articulates the foundational principles and then engages the larger Muslim community in dialogue to create a new awareness and to translate the articulated principles into a living tradition. Reform aimed at critically engage Muslim traditions must stick closely to the Qur'an and prophetic practices, to clarify Islamic injunctions and established prophetic traditions. The Progressive Muslim Union's leaders have apparently decided to push the envelop beyond all limits and operate in revolutionary rather than a reformist mode.

It is quite apparent that Muslim reformers, concerned with evolving the practices of the American Muslim community, and ensuring the full and meaningful inclusion of women in community life, must navigate their way by maintaining a middle ground, away from extremist tendencies: away from extreme conservative tendencies obsessed with preserving cultural traditions even at the expense of distorting Islamic teachings, and from extreme liberal outbursts that want to break fully with all traditions and delve into an empty space with no directions and road signs. 

10 Comments:

Yet another excellent commentary. Your voice of moderation, openness and understanding that brings two opposite sides together is in the true spirit of Islam.

By Mohamed Fakhreddine, at March 15, 2005 10:04 PM  

Al-salam alaykum. Dr. Wadud and the Progressive Muslim Union argue that it is not they, but those who deny Muslim women full equality of access to leadership, who are the ones who have broken away from Quranic principles and prophetic practices. Instead of dismissing the position of PMU out of hand, it would be better to give a reasoned argument addressing the points they raise. See, e.g., "What Would the Prophet Do? The Islamic Basis for Female-Led Prayer" (http://www.muslimwakeup.com/main/archives/2005/03/women_imamat.php).

In particular, I have never seen any opponent of full equality for women who would squarely address the claim that the Prophet commanded Umm Waraqah to lead the congregational prayers for the men and women of her area. Instead, the example of Umm Waraqah is usually brushed aside and the claim is advanced that the Prophet never appointed any women to such leadership. But even discounting the example of Umm Waraqah, I have not seen anyone who could point to a reliable report that the Prophet actively denied any leadership position to someone who was otherwise fully qualified for the post, solely because that person was a woman.

By Faruq Nelson, at March 18, 2005 8:53 PM  

I agree that Muslim men and women are ethically and spiritually equal in Islamic law. Both are responsible for their actions before Allah in the hereafter. The question is does Islam acknowledge physical equality between Muslim men and women? There have been arrangements during the congregational prayers that men are in the front, followed by male chlidren and then followed by woand female children. Who made such arrangements and what are their bases?ses?

By Anonymous, at March 18, 2005 11:57 PM  

Salaams,
The author's view is of great significance but falls short of taking into account more progressive voice of Muslim intellectuals (Ulema) of Shia-tradition. For instance, one can mention the ideas of Ayatullah Sanei which could prove profoundly instrumental in the American context. The questiosn of religion could not be divorced from issues of intelligence, i.e. we need intelligent minds who can distinguish between the universality of Sunna and locality of people who formulate this universal Sunna in each epoch.
wa al-salaam
Dr. S. Javad M. Meynagh
University of Harbin
Department of Human Sciences
Harbin
China

By Bristol, at March 19, 2005 4:58 AM  

Your article on the above subject was quite interesting and informative. As everybody was waiting, the mixed congration of brothers and sisters was led by a sister the other day in New York! As in the opinion of most Muslims around the world is a violation of the Islamic Principle. We fear this pracrice-Bidah (Innovation) spreads and gives good ground for the West and the people within Islam who always look for some excuse and distort the Interpretation of Holy Qur'an!

We hope and pray, May Allah (swt) give wisdom to all Believers to follow the True Relgion of Islam within its bounds.

By Roshanali Lakhani, at April 26, 2005 9:03 AM  

According Sahih Buqhari Hadeeths I have read and understood, women use to pray in Masjid at the back.
Muhammad (sws) use to wait after (Fajr and Isha) prayers and asked Sahabas to wait also and to leave after women.

Men were told not to stop women if they wanted to pray in Masjid even Fajr and Isha prayers.

A woman, who stood up in the middle of the masjid and pointed out second Caliph Umar bin al-Khatab (raa)'s proposed policy to put a cap on dowry, violated Islamic law.
It is not clear at least to me, was women in the women's section? or were women allowed to inter-mingle with men?

Umm Waraqah who was knowledgeable in Quran, only lead her house hold staff and not Friday Mixed Gender Congressional Prayers.

In "Swinging to the Other Extreme" you did not mention Women leading Friday Congressional Prayers is not revolutionary it is invention in Islam which is Bidah (Innovation) and Fitnah.

So called Progressive Muslims Reformists are reading from the same Zionist Agenda page or being paid by them.

We should not try to please them or be appologetic and be on the defencive. We should follow Quran and Sunnah only try to please Allah (swt). We are only answerable to Allah on the Day of Judgement.

May Allah and all of you forgive me if I said anything wrong. All good is from Allah everything bad is from me.

Wassalam,

By Anonymous, at May 08, 2005 1:58 AM  

This is an excellent piece of writing typifying of what Muslims need most: enlightened scholarship that inspires itself from the Quran, the Hadiths and commonsense. It is complete nonsense to compete women out of the mosque and allow the traditions to have a force bigger than the Quran, which is the ultimate truth.

I am very proud to have read this piece and may Allah keep this type of substance flowing through your website.

By Alassane Diakite, at January 12, 2006 5:35 PM  

I am fascinated about the article i have just read its a step in the development of the spiritual growth of the muslim woman.our femail counterparts are far behind in terms of their active participation in the growth of islam .They feel isolated in many instances it saddens my heart

By mustapha braimah, at January 12, 2006 5:36 PM  

I agree with the article, that the Islamic Centers MUST become mroe woman friendly. Having traveled extensively to many Masajid, I can honestly say that those Islamic Centers/Masajid that were the strongest were those with the strongest women's programs. The woman is the central figure in the community, and as she goes, the community goes.

The sad part of this, as is stated, is that the extreme feminists have shifted the debate to a point that if one calls for a woman friendly masjid, then people think that you are calling for a woman to be imam or something.

We hope that the reform (or better called revival of the Sunnah) agenda continues

By Anonymous, at March 02, 2006 6:44 PM  

Yet another excellent commentary. Your voice of moderation, openness and understanding that brings two opposite sides together is in the true spirit of Islam.

By Mohamed Fakhreddine

By Mohamed Fakhreddine, at September 03, 2007 
 


User Comments

Please login or register to add comments

Quotable




The Qur'anic Narrative
The Qur'anic Narrative


Leading with Compassion
Leading with Compassion



Palestine
Palestine



tensions-and-transitions.gif 
Tensions and Transitions
in the Muslim World



peace.gif
Peace and the Limits of War


Challenge-of-Modernity
The Challenge of Modernity 


Blaming

Blaming Islam


images/stories/foundation.jpg
Foundation of Knowledge



Creative Commons License